Instagram story sticker tap problem

Hiya guys. I would like to set up an automation when someone clicks the emoji stick in my stories. But when I go to set it up in Manychat, if I say “click on a specific story” it only shows my first instagram story, not the following ones afterwards (which is where my stick is, on the 4th story, not the first). Is there a way to change this, or is the only option to do it on the first story? TIA